Aganool #20: Arattai Effect - What looks "hopelessly foolish" today might be your advantage tomorrow


Issue 20

October 4th 2025

Rethinking how we measure progress in our careers

The messaging app Arattai, developed by Zoho, is making the news recently for all the right reasons. The messaging app went from 3000 downloads per day to almost 350,000 per day over the last few weeks.

The growth was so rapid that the app reached the top position in Apple’s App Store charts for the “Social Networking” category in India

What caught my attention was not what caused the surge in traffic but how this app has survived for so long.

While Arattai might be riding on the tailwinds of surging nationalism and endorsement from the government, it is not a new app.

In fact, it was soft-launched in early 2021 and going by the numbers, my estimate is that it would have had less than 1 lakh users before September. In contrast, Whatsapp has around 500 Million (5 Crore) active users in India.

This metric is enough to kill such a project a long time ago.

Why waste resource and infrastructure on a project that has a established player in the market which will be hard to dislodge?

The answer lies in how the founder’s define Zoho as a company. Zoho hasn’t gone public after 29 years in business and making more than billion dollars in revenue annually.

In response to comments that Zoho should go public, the founder Sridhar Vembu says the reason for this is that “Zoho is a kind of an industrial research lab that also makes money to fund itself. We essentially ignore short term profits, as long as we don’t lose money. And we have a culture of founders and senior executives living frugally”

When Arattai was developed, his employees called it a “hopelessly foolish” project. But they did it anyway.

A public company that focuses on growth, quarterly targets, share prices would have nipped it in the bud. Imagine announcing during your shareholders meeting that you are investing resources to create a messaging app similar to Whatsapp.

The freedom that Zoho gets by remaining private could not be appreciated if one looks at just the bottomline growth every year.

Zoho as a company embodies the values of Sridhar Vembu as an individual.

And I think every individual needs to look at their professional life in the same way.

The work you do should embody the person you are. We treat our career as a publicly traded company taking the safe route, always looking for bottomline growth even if it meant taking us away from who we truly are.

But if we take a page out of Zoho’s book, there’s another way to play the game.

You can choose to treat your career like a private company.

A private company has the freedom to experiment, to invest in projects that might look foolish to others, and to pursue long-term bets without obsessing over quarterly results.

Similarly, you can:

  • Explore skills or interests that might not “pay off” immediately.
  • Work on side projects that align with your values, even if they don’t look impressive on LinkedIn.
  • Say no to roles or opportunities that grow your bank account but shrink your sense of identity.

If a company, that employs more than 28,000, can resist the temptation to play the Wall Street game and still succeed; I don’t think we should treat our own career like a stock that needs to be constantly traded for short-term gains.

Play the long game. Build a career that funds your curiosity, reflects your values, and compounds quietly until one day, like Arattai, it suddenly looks like an “overnight success.

If you think this newsletter will be useful to someone else, feel free to forward it.

And If you were forwarded this newsletter, you can read all previous issues and also subscribe to the newsletter here. Make sure to click the confirmation email once you subscribe

I hope you enjoyed this week's version. See you next week.

Best wishes,

Nimalan.

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Aganool

I love to observe, think & write. Aganool is where my reflections take shape — a written companion drawn from inner observations and thoughtful analysis. You will love it if you are a Professional navigating career decisions, an Entrepreneur taking tough choices each day or anyone who is figuring out the journey called life. This newsletter is your thinking partner for navigating work and life with clarity, strategy, and emotional intelligence. Check your email to confirm subscription.

Read more from Aganool

Issue 27 December 14th 2025 Breaking the Autopilot Without Breaking Routine ↓ I recently mentioned to a colleague outside my team that I will be leaving the company in December. He was shocked and remarked, “ It just feels like you started here recently. How long has it been? 3 years already? Time flies fast eh!!!” We talked a bit about how my current role would be managed by the team moving forward and some of the challenges that would come with it. As the conversation moved towards what my...

Issue 26 November 30th 2025 A framework for navigating ambition without ego in today’s high stakes environments. ↓ I was having a chat earlier this week with my brother who is working in the US. We talked a bit about the current corporate ecosystem and how it feels to be an Indian working in the US. He mentioned that “Indians, especially South Indians, are usually too humble in a corporate environment and do not like to show off their work”. This statement felt a bit paradoxical to me. True,...

Issue 25 November 15th 2025 The world remembers the useful, not the merely successful. ↓ When I said that I would be moving to the public sector after working more than 5 years in the private sector, the first question that people asked was if the pay is competitive. I’m not going to lie, but pay was definitely one criteria that I myself wasn’t ready to downscale. I was happy as long as I got paid whatever I earned in the private sector at that time. The relatively lower pay in the public...